Thursday, November 19, 2026

Piermont Mayor Mitchell’s Silt-Fence Dog-and-Pony Show.

The trees came down. The neighbors came to Piermont Village Hall. And on November 10, 2026, Marshmallow Mayor had an enforcement-announcement for the people of Piermont:
 
Two deficiencies in the silt-fencing at the Phil Griffin construction site.
 
If the developer failed to address them, then the Village could assess fines.
 
Could.
 
1. Twenty-Five Seconds Under “Old Business”. At about [00:01:38] of the November 10, 2026 Village of Piermont Board of Trustees meeting, Mayor Nate Mitchell brought up the Phil Griffin “Piermont Village Green” project under “Old Business”. Mitchell assured those listening that stormwater pollution prevention inspections had been taking place. Mitchell also volunteered that an Inspector - presumably Piermont Building Inspector Charlie Schaub - had found two deficiencies in the silt-fencing at the Griffin site. Mitchell indicated that those deficiencies had been advised to the developer to address.
 
Then came the enforcement part. If you want to call it that.
 
Mitchell said:
 
“If they fail to address it, there are fines that we can assess against them on a[n] ongoing basis”.
 
See November 10, 2026 Village of Piermont Board of Trustees meeting, “Old Business”, [00:01:38–00:02:03]:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4BoK4GwN0I&t=98s
 
Then the meeting moved merrily along to “New Business”.
 
It had to have been intentional on Mayor Mitchell’s part to provide such scant little information on what he was talking about. What were those two defects, Marshmallow Mayor? When did the Inspector find them? How long was the developer given to fix them? Was there any written citation, ticket, or other form of notice? And, since then, has anyone in Piermont village government actually gone back to check?
 
Mitchell supplied none of those particulars. None. He announced no fine. He told us that fines could, perhaps, maybe follow. It was the dog-and-pony show starring Nate Mitchell and Phil Griffin. Practically the whole Village of Piermont has been enraged about the Griffin clear-cutting since it started. This was Nate trying to sound like he was getting tough with the developer. 

As a result, the public got twenty-five seconds and a conditional verb.
 
In Nate Mitchell’s milquetoast world, apparently, twenty-five seconds is all it takes. Hell, in Nate Mitchell’s milquetoast world, the lyrics of a Carly Rae Jepsen song would constitute an overly-forward come-on. This is probably how Mitchell and Schaub cited Griffin:
 
“Hey, I Just Met You.
And This Is Crazy.
But Here’s My Number.
So Call Me, Maybe.
It’s Hard To Look Right...
At You, Baby.
But Here’s My Number.
So Call Me, Maybe.”
 
2. The Silt Fence Was Already On-Paper. The “Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan” for Phil Griffin’s Piermont Village Green project posted in the Village’s Planning Board records, includes this step in its construction sequence:
 
“Install silt fence… down slope of all areas to be disturbed”.
 
See Piermont Village Green Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan, construction sequence, step 4:
https://cms9files1.revize.com/piermont/document_center/Department/Planning%20%26%20Zoning%20Board/Planning%20Board/Plan_Board_Documents/2022/1-10-22/2021-9-20_SWPPP_06112-Revised.pdf
 
“Areas to be disturbed”.
 
Let’s see the version of the plan that actually governed the work. Let’s see the inspection records reflecting what was in place when the Grifin clear-cutting first began. Were these two silt-fence “deficiencies” there from the start? Or, did they materialize thereafter during the clear-cutting? How long have they gone uncorrected? Nate Mitchell’s November 10, 2026 non-announcement leaves the entire chronology blank.


3. Three Weeks Earlier, Nate Mitchell Already Knew What to Ask About. At the October 20, 2026 Village of Piermont Board of Trustees meeting, Piermont resident Sergei Tazin raised concerns about Phil Griffin’s Village Green construction site and the activities related thereto. The minutes of that meeting record Mitchell’s account of what the existing approvals covered, including the “roadway, sewer, water, gas, retaining wall, and stormwater collection and retention systems”. [Emphasis added]. See October 20, 2026 Village of Piermont Board of Trustees minutes, p.2 of 4, Item #6, “Public Comment”:
https://www.piermont-ny.gov/AgendaCenter/ViewFile/Minutes/_10202026-138
 
In the October 20, 2026 meeting, Mitchell indicated that, out of his claimed concerns regarding erosion and runoff at 
the Village Green construction site, he had raised the “Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan” with Piermont Building Inspector Charlie Schaub. Later in the same meeting, Schaub explained that he, Schaub, can enforce the site-plan approved by the Piermont Planning Board. See October 20, 2026 Village of Piermont Board of Trustees meeting. Mitchell at [00:15:11–00:15:37]; Schaub at [00:24:50–00:25:06]:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8gJ5w8TxTI&t=911s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8gJ5w8TxTI&t=1490s
 
So on October 20, 2026, Mayor Mitchell was already talking about erosion and runoff at 
Phil Griffin’s Village Green construction site. Building Inspector Schaub was already explaining what he could enforce. Then on November 10, 2026, the Mayor finally gave us something “more specific”. Two deficiencies. That should have been the beginning of the public accounting. Instead, it was the whole announcement, and the end of it.
 
4. Let’s See What the Village Actually Did. This was Mitchell’s slap on Phil Griffin’s wrist dressed up for a Board meeting. It’s the kind of performance that makes all of us know whose interests Marshmallow Mayor is really looking out for during his foreseeably-limited two-year term in office. Phil Griffin, the developer, gets the opportunity to correct two cryptic silt-fence failings. In turn, Piermont gets a reminder that the Village has the power to impose fines. Great. Yet the residents who watched the strafing of the Griffin “Village Green” land, and watched all the trees come down, are still left asking what oversight of the awful project was in place when it could have made a difference.
 
So, Nate. Two deficiencies. What were they? What deadline did you and Piermont village government give the developer? Who if anybody went back to check? And what if anything happened when they did?
 
Let’s see the dated inspection reports. Let’s see the written notice if there was one. Let’s see the follow-up.
 
If this developer missed a deadline, let’s see what if anything your village did about it.
 
For that matter, let’s see what you actually intend to do about “stormwater pollution prevention”, even in those cases wherein the pollution may be threatened to be caused by a developer who has you fit snugly into their pocket.
 
You told us what Piermont could do.
 
Now tell us what Piermont did.